Brilliant Earth Review: My Honest Review, 2023

Brilliant Earth first popped onto my radar when I was looking for a new bracelet to celebrate my wedding anniversary. Endless amounts of googling trying to find the perfect gift lead me directly to the Brilliant Earth website.  Ever since my husband ordered my first piece of jewelry from Brilliant Earth and I showcased it on instagram stories, “hello white Gold Diamond tennis bracelet,” I’ve been receiving endless amounts of questions. 

Brilliant Earth Review Diamond Tennis Bracelet
Diane wearing a Brilliant Earth Diamond Tennis Bracelet

History of Brilliant Earth

founder of brilliant earth
Founder of Brilliant Earth © Brilliant Earth

I love companies that are disrupting industries and making big changes to the fashion, handbag and jewelry world. One of those companies that is disrupting the jewelry industry is none other than jewelry company Brilliant Earth. Let’s take a look back at the Brilliant Earth history and see where it all began.

Brilliant Earth was created by a challenge co-founder Beth Gerstein faced in 2005 when looking for an engagement ring…she wanted an engagement ring with an ethically sourced and conflict free diamond. On the outside this task seems simple, but in 2005 that wasn’t the case. Keep in mind it wasn’t really until the movie “Blood Diamond” was released a year later in 2006, that the general public truly understood the diamond industry and how conflict diamonds were sourced. Gerstein partnered with classmate Eric Grossberg to create a sustainable, conflict free place to buy jewelry known as Brilliant Earth

My honest opinion on Brilliant Earth Jewelry

brilliant earth diamond tennis bracelet and diamond ring
Brilliant Earth Review

Welcome to a comprehensive Brilliant Earth Guide! To be honest with you, I can’t begin to tell you how excited I was for my diamond tennis bracelet to arrive.  I was like a kid at a candy store! Believe me when I tell you, I watched that tracking number like a hawk. I may or may not have even got a little giddy when I heard the doorbell ring. 

As soon as I signed for my package, I couldn’t wait to open the Brilliant Earth diamond bracelet! As soon as I opened that eco-friendly wooden box I was speechless. There lies one of the most investment worthy jewelry pieces I’ve been dying to add to my jewelry collection: A diamond tennis bracelet! 

My first impression of the Diamond bracelet was that I was truly blown away. This one-carat diamond tennis bracelet is priced at a little over $2,000 and I absolutely adore it! Similar to the Brilliant Earth diamond engagement rings, the tennis bracelet has multiple different customization options to choose from, for example: Do I want a Natural Diamond tennis bracelet or a Lab Grown Diamond tennis bracelet, in white gold or yellow gold and how many carats do I want for the diamond bracelet? 

I love being able to see and choose different options based upon my needs. Even though my engagement ring is set in yellow gold, I ended up deciding on a white 1 Carat Diamond tennis bracelet! This the perfect anniversary gift! Shop Brilliant Earth Tennis Bracelets & Shop Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings.

What is the quality of Brilliant Earth Jewelry?

Brilliant Earth Engagement Ring Review
Diamond Tennis Bracelet and Engagement Ring · Brilliant Earth Review

I was so impressed by the quality of the Brilliant Earth diamonds. I’m not a diamond expert, but an experienced luxury jewelry shopper and I noticed that the diamonds sparkled endlessly, were held together securely by the white gold prongs ensuring the diamonds wouldn’t fall out, and has an extremely high quality clasp. In short, the quality of the Brilliant Earth diamonds is immaculate.  

I’m impressed by their high quality diamonds, gold and the quality of the piece of jewelry. With that being said, another question I received was all about buying jewelry and buying engagement rings online! 

Is it safe to buy jewelry online?

The most popular question that I received from my followers in regards to buying jewelry online was “is it safe to buy jewelry online”. Or even questions such as I’ve always purchased jewelry at a store because I feel an emotional connection to the piece, will I feel the same way if I purchase the jewelry online? 

The short answer is yes, it is safe to buy jewelry online, and you will still have that same emotional connection to that piece of jewelry. In fact, I strongly believe this is the best way to buy jewelry. Brilliant Earth has 27 showrooms in all major markets across the US!

Brilliant Earth offers an incredible online customization feature to create and design your own engagement ring with a diamond or gemstone (Sapphires, Emeralds, Aquamarine, Morganite, Moissanite). This allows you to customize your engagement ring based upon your needs and fit within your budget.

What type of Diamonds does Brilliant Earth Carry?

brilliant earth diamond tennis bracelet and Brilliant earth box
Brilliant Earth Tennis Bracelet Review

If you are looking to purchase an engagement ring from Brilliant Earth you are in luck because Brilliant Earth carries both Natural Diamonds and Lab Grown diamonds. Natural Diamonds and Lab Grown Diamonds have identical physical, chemical and optical components. Meaning to the naked eye they look exactly the same!

The main difference between the Natural diamonds and Lab grown diamonds is that natural diamonds take thousands of years to be made, while lab grown diamonds can be created in a few months. The second difference is Lab Grown diamonds are more affordable than natural diamonds. All their diamonds are conflict-free, beyond conflict free, ethically sourced, and mindfully made!

In my opinion, it comes down to a personal choice whether you decide to purchase a natural diamond or a lab grown diamond. It is important to note that all the engagement rings come with an appraisal, warranty and as an added bonus if you spend over a certain amount they include a free gift (this free gift varies based upon the month), plus let’s not forget about free shipping! Shop online Brilliant Earth Lab Grown Diamonds & Shop Online Brilliant Earth Natural Earth Diamonds.

How much does a Brilliant Earth Engagement Ring Cost?

Brilliant Earth Review Engagement Ring
Brilliant Earth Engagement Ring © Brilliant Earth

How much does a Brilliant Earth engagement ring cost is such a tough question to answer. There are so many different factors and variables that make up the cost of an engagement ring. With that being said the prices on an engagement ring start at less than $1,000 and go up from there. Yes, you read that correctly, you can buy a high quality engagement ring at Brilliant Earth for less than $1k!

What if the Engagement ring is the wrong size?

Brilliant Earth Engagement Ring Wrong size
Brilliant Earth Engagement Ring © Brilliant Earth

One of the most popular concerns when buying an engagement ring online is what if I order the wrong size? Or the ring arrives and it’s the wrong size and needs to be resized? How does that work? After doing some simple research on the Brilliant Earth website, I found the answer you are looking for! 

Brilliant Earth has someone working 24/7 at customer service with a live chat, in case you have a question, they offer free 60 day resizing and get this Brilliant Earth pays for the shipping both ways! Therefore, If you discover that the size of the engagement ring is wrong or it doesn’t fit, you won't have to worry! Keep in mind this same policy also goes for if you order wedding rings, wedding bands, engagement rings.

Does Brilliant Earth offer a warranty?

brilliant earth diamond tennis bracelet logo
Brilliant Earth Logo with diamon bracelet

When making a big purchase online it is important to be familiar with the warranty / lifetime warranty or the guarantee if something happens to your engagement ring or piece of jewelry. After doing some research on the Brilliant Earth website, I was surprised by Brilliant Earth’s lifetime warranty and lifetime diamond upgrade policy. 

If a repair is needed due to manufacturing defects, Brilliant Earth provides a lifetime warranty! The lifetime diamond upgrade program, Brilliant Earth allows you to exchange and upgrade natural diamonds. The natural diamond purchased on Brilliant Earth can be exchanged for a credit equivalent of the original purchase price to purchase a new diamond that is 50% greater value!

Lifetime Warranty and a diamond lifetime upgrade policy is an incredible benefit that Brilliant Earth offers! So cool!! You can read all the details about Brilliant Earth’s warranty policy here!

Does Brilliant Earth offer affordable jewelry or only diamond jewelry?

Brilliant Earth Jewelry Review 2022
Brilliant Earth Review 2022

Brilliant Earth offers more than engagement rings! It’s a one-stop shop for buying high quality jewelry. The easy-to-use website and filters makes it simple to find exactly what you are looking for. In fact, Brilliant Earth is always adding new collections including it's new cocktail rings, Truly Brilliant Diamonds, Sustainably Rated Lab Diamonds.

Is Brilliant Earth worth the price?

brilliant earth diamond tennis bracelet review
Brilliant Earth Review · Brilliant Earth Diamonds

The question of the day, is Brilliant Earth worth the price? The answer is yes a million times over! Yes, Brilliant Earth is definitely worth the price! Brilliant Earth’s jewelry is high quality, made extremely well and will definitely last a lifetime. 

Brilliant Earth jewelry is sourced from ethical and beyond conflict free diamonds, with a listed origin of Canada, Botswana, Namibia, and South Africa. jewelry. Brilliant Earth uses recycled gold, platinum and silver. In addition to the high quality, there are so many benefits when purchasing from Brilliant Earth such as a lifetime warranty, free appraisal, free resizing for 60 days, free returns up to 30 days, free lifetime diamond upgrade, free engraving and so much more! The Brilliant Earth engagement ring or Brilliant Earth jewelry comes with an appraisal to make it easy to submit to the insurance company. 

I have been wearing my diamond tennis bracelet non-stop, and I receive endless amounts of compliments on it. The high quality diamonds are apparent in the way the bracelet sparkles! Not to mention, I can’t stop staring at it! I’m in total awe of this bracelet. Shop The Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings website.

Recap of my Brilliant Earth Review

I’m absolutely blown away by my diamond tennis bracelet, and I highly recommend Brilliant Earth! If you are on the fence about purchasing jewelry from Brilliant Earth or purchasing an Engagement Ring from Brilliant Earth, I hope this comprehensive Brilliant Earth Review helped in your decision! As always, I’m happy to answer questions you may have about Brilliant Earth in the comments!

Sincerely Petite in Paris,


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *